Eastern Numismatics Review

Disclaimer: All or some companies listed may provide us with compensation. That is how we provide our customers with our great free services. Compensation coupled with extensive in-depth research, determines how and where companies below appear.

Eastern Numismatics

Eastern Numismatics Inc. is one of the largest rare coin dealers in the United States, with over 40 years of experience in the industry. They offer a wide range of services, including buying and selling coins and precious metals, appraisals, auctions, and more. 

Customers have consistently praised Eastern Numismatics Inc. for their exceptional customer service and knowledge in the coin-collecting world. They have a highly trained and experienced team, with many holding professional numismatic certifications, such as the Professional Numismatists Guild (PNG) and the American Numismatic Association (ANA). 

Read on to know more about whether you can trust Eastern Numismatics Inc.

About Eastern Numismatics Inc. 

Eastern Numismatics Inc. was founded in 1978 by Barry Stuppler, who is currently serving as the company's president. They have offices in New York and California, allowing them to serve a wide range of customers. In addition to buying and selling coins and precious metals, they also offer auctions, appraisals, consultation services, and more. 

Pros and Cons


  • Extensive experience in the industry
  • Wide range of services offered
  • Highly trained and knowledgeable staff
  • Excellent customer service


  • Limited physical locations (just New York and California)
1oz Gold Krugerrand coins front and back

Products Offered

Eastern Numismatics Inc. offers a wide range of products, including rare coins, precious metals, and paper currency. They specialize in U.S. coins and have an impressive inventory of early American coins, colonial coins, type coins, gold coins, and more. 

They also offer precious metal bullion in the form of gold bars and silver bars, as well as precious metal coins such as American Silver Eagles and Canadian Maple Leafs. 

In addition, they also carry paper currency from various countries. 

CENTS Program

Eastern Numismatics Inc. has a CENTS (Coin Exchange and Trade System) program where customers can trade their coins for credit for future purchases from Eastern Numismatics Inc. This allows for an easy and seamless trading process for customers looking to add new pieces to their collection or investment portfolio.


Eastern Numismatics Inc. also offers a HALF CENTS (Highest Asset Liquidation for Fast Cash) program, where customers can quickly and easily sell their coins at competitive market rates. The team at Eastern Numismatics Inc. will provide a fair assessment of the coins and make an offer within 24 hours, allowing for a convenient and hassle-free selling process.

DIMES Program

Eastern Numismatics Inc. also has a DIMES (Direct Investor Marketing and Estate Sales) program, where they assist with liquidating large coin collections or estates. This can include personalized marketing strategies, expert appraisal services, and assistance with the sales process.


Eastern Numismatics Inc. also offers QUARTERS (Quick, Unbiased Appraisal and Real-Time Evaluation Services) for customers looking to sell or trade their coins. They provide a quick and accurate assessment of the coin(s), allowing customers to make informed decisions on their next steps.


In addition, Eastern Numismatics Inc. also offers HALF DOLLARS (Honest Advice for Long-term Investment and Future Financial Security) services, where their team of experts can provide personalized advice and guidance on building a strong and successful coin investment portfolio. They can assist with creating a balanced and diverse portfolio and strategizing for potential growth and future financial security.


Eastern Numismatics Inc. also offers SILVER DOLLARS (Silver Investment Liquidation and Value Enhancement Results) services for customers looking to invest in or liquidate their silver holdings. Their team of experts can provide valuable insights and assistance in making the best decisions for silver investments and sales.

Business Practices and Policies

Eastern Numismatics Inc. is a member of the Professional Numismatists Guild (PNG) and the American Numismatic Association (ANA), two prestigious organizations in the coin-collecting industry. As a member, they must adhere to a strict code of ethics and professionalism. 

Their website offers information on buying and selling policies, returns, and privacy policies. They also have a frequently asked questions section that addresses common concerns such as shipping and payment options. 


Eastern Numismatics Inc. offers competitive product prices and fair appraisals and consultation rates. They also offer financing options through Credova, a third-party financial service provider.


Eastern Numismatics Inc. offers free domestic shipping for orders over $500 and ships internationally for an additional fee.


Eastern Numismatics Inc. offers storage solutions for their customers, including vault storage and offshore storage options.


Eastern Numismatics Inc. has a 14-day return policy for items that are not as described. They also offer a satisfaction guarantee for their appraisal and consultation services.

Trustworthiness and Business Reputation

Eastern Numismatics Inc. has a strong reputation in the coin-collecting community, with many customers praising their exceptional customer service and knowledge in the industry. They have received numerous positive reviews on third-party websites such as Trustpilot and Yelp.

Real Customer Reviews

Eastern Numismatics has been an invaluable resource for my coin collection. Their expertise and customer service are top-notch, and I always feel confident in their guidance. Highly recommend!

Michelle B.

I have been dealing with Eastern Numismatics for over 25 years and have never had a negative experience. They are knowledgeable, fair and go above and beyond to ensure customer satisfaction. I highly recommend them!

Mike W.

I can always rely on Eastern Numismatics for expert advice and high-quality coins. They have a fantastic selection, and their staff is friendly and helpful. Definitely one of my go-to dealers.

Melissa S.

I am new to coin collecting, and Eastern Numismatics has been amazing in helping me navigate the hobby. They have a great selection of coins, and their staff is extremely knowledgeable. Would highly recommend!

Stephanie P.

You cannot go wrong with Eastern Numismatics. They have a wide selection of coins and precious metals, and their staff is always willing to go the extra mile for their customers. I trust them with all my coin collecting needs.

Jason M.

Eastern Numismatics Inc. is by far the best dealer I have worked with. They have a great selection, and their staff is very knowledgeable and helpful. They make coin collecting a breeze!

Marie C.


Eastern Numismatics Inc. takes the security of its customer's personal information and payments very seriously. They use a secure website and encryption technology to protect sensitive data and offer payment options through trusted third-party providers such as PayPal and Credova. Furthermore, they are registered with the United States Department of Treasury as a Money Services Business. 


Eastern Numismatics Inc. has won numerous awards, including the Numismatic Literary Guild's "Dealer of the Year" award and multiple ANA Awards for their educational exhibits and displays at coin conventions. They have also been featured in industry publications such as The Numismatist and Coin World. 

Service Locations

Eastern Numismatics Inc. is located in Garden City, New York, and has a satellite office in Boca Raton, Florida. They attend major coin conventions throughout the country to meet with clients and showcase their merchandise. Additionally, they offer online purchasing options for customer convenience. 

Warranty and Insurances

Eastern Numismatics Inc. offers a warranty on all coins and precious metals purchased from them and insurance options for secure storage and shipping. They also offer appraisal services with insurance coverage for added peace of mind. 

Shipping Options

Eastern Numismatics Inc. offers a variety of shipping options for their customers, including overnight and international shipping. 

Price Match Policy

Eastern Numismatics Inc. has a price match policy to ensure that its customers get the best deal possible on their purchases. Eastern Numismatics Inc. will match or beat that price if a customer finds the same product listed for a lower price at another dealer. 

Not a Scam

Eastern Numismatics Inc. is a legitimate, reputable coin dealership with over 40 years of experience in the industry. They are members of numerous industry organizations, such as the Professional Numismatists Guild and the American Numismatic Association, and they adhere to strict ethical guidelines set forth by these organizations. 

Customer Service

Eastern Numismatics Inc. prides itself on exceptional customer service. Their knowledgeable staff is always happy to assist with questions and concerns, and they have a straightforward return policy for dissatisfied customers.

BBB Rating

Eastern Numismatics Inc. has an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau and has been a BBB-accredited business since 2010. 

Trial Period

Eastern Numismatics Inc. offers a seven-day trial period for their customers to ensure satisfaction with their purchases. If a customer is unsatisfied within that time frame, they may return the item for a full refund. 

What to Do If You Don't Trust Them?

If customers do not trust Eastern Numismatics Inc., they are encouraged to conduct their research and due diligence before purchasing. 

This can include checking the dealer's ratings and reviews with the BBB and industry organizations and asking for references from other customers. Additionally, customers can choose to pay through a trusted third-party payment provider for added security.

How Do They Charge for Their Products' Value?

Eastern Numismatics Inc. bases the prices of its products on current market value and demand, as well as any rarity or collectability factors.

Why Don't They Accept Cash?

For security reasons, Eastern Numismatics Inc. does not accept cash payments. They offer various secure payment options such as credit card, check, wire transfer, and third-party payment providers. 

Steps of Buying from Eastern Numismatics Inc.

  1. 1
    Contact Eastern Numismatics Inc. to inquire about a specific product or to request a price quote.
  2. 2
    Choose a payment option and pay for the product(s).
  3. 3
    Eastern Numismatics Inc. will securely package and ship the product(s) to the customer's specified location.
  4. 4
    If needed, the customer may utilize Eastern Numismatics Inc.'s warranty and insurance options for their purchase.
  5. 5
    Enjoy your new coins or precious metals from Eastern Numismatics Inc.!

Discounts Offered by Eastern Numismatics Inc.

Eastern Numismatics Inc. offers discounts for bulk purchases and members of certain industry organizations. They also have a referral program, where customers can receive a discount for referring friends and family to make purchases with Eastern Numismatics Inc. 

Grading Standards

Eastern Numismatics Inc. follows industry standard grading guidelines set by organizations such as the Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS) and Numismatic Guaranty Corporation (NGC). They also have their own in-house grading team of experts who provide an unbiased and accurate assessment of a coin's condition before it is added to their inventory. 

Why Invest in Gold Coins?

Gold coins can serve as a hedge against inflation and economic uncertainty. They also have the potential to increase in value over time, making them valuable to any investment portfolio. Eastern Numismatics Inc. offers a wide selection of reputable gold coins from various countries and periods. 

Why Invest in Rare Coins?

Rare coins can be an exciting addition to a collection and have the potential for significant value appreciation over time. Eastern Numismatics Inc. has a team of experts who carefully curate their inventory of rare coins, ensuring that customers receive high-quality and authentic pieces. 

Who can buy precious metal coins?

Anyone can purchase precious metal coins, whether it's for investment or collecting purposes. Eastern Numismatics Inc. assists first-time buyers, and seasoned collectors find the right coin(s) for their needs and goals. 

Adding Gold to IRA

Eastern Numismatics Inc. helps add physical gold coins to an Individual Retirement Account (IRA). This can provide diversity and stability to a retirement portfolio, as well as the potential for growth in value over time. Customers can contact Eastern Numismatics Inc. for more information on this process. 

This process will start with a consultation with one of their experts to ensure that the gold coins meet the IRS requirements for IRAs. Then, they will assist in setting up or transferring an existing IRA account and completing the necessary paperwork. The physical gold coins will then be securely stored for the customer in an IRS-approved depository.

Final Verdict

Overall, Eastern Numismatics Inc. is a trusted and reputable coin dealership with a strong history in the industry and exceptional customer service. They offer competitive pricing and even have discounts available for certain customers. If you're in the market for coins or precious metals, definitely consider giving Eastern Numismatics Inc. a try!